Andrew Henry on Why Religion Is So Hard to Define
Scholar Andrew Henry explains why religion resists definition. He argues for looking at what practices do, from creeds to stadium chants.
Scholars of religion still can’t agree on what religion is, and Andrew Henry, creator of Religion for Breakfast, thinks that tells us something. In this conversation with Jonny Thomson, he explains why he looks at what religious practices do rather than what they claim, why a stadium chant and a church creed may be closer than they seem, and why “true Christianity” is harder to pin down than its defenders suggest. They also take on common debate points, from the historical Jesus to Tom Holland’s claim that Western values are Christian at heart.
Summoning a demon in the Roman Empire
Jonny Thomson: Hello everybody and welcome to today’s live conversation. Today joining me is Dr. Andrew Henry, a scholar of religion and best known for his hugely popular YouTube channel Religion for Breakfast. Andrew holds a PhD in religious studies from Boston University where he studied magic and demonology in the late Roman Empire. And today we are exploring what people tend to get wrong about religion, what are the common misrepresentations and straw men that exist in the debate between all parties. So before this conversation, I asked members of the community and people on social media for some questions, about what they consider to be either straw men or misrepresentations or common kind of debating points.
And so I thought we might talk about some of them according to different categories like Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, paganism, etc. But before that, I have to know, how do you summon the demon in the Roman Empire?
Andrew Henry: Oh, man, that’s a good question. So it’s a tricky question because when we think of demon, it’s such a Christian concept. So it’s a very polarized concept that you have demons on one side and angels on the other side. The word demon actually comes from the Greek daimones. And especially in, you know, Classical Greek era, it really referred to, I mean, the Homeric hymns, it refers to gods. It’s a word that can refer to a god like Zeus or Hera. By the time you get to Plato, it can refer to ambiguous spirits that kind of inhabit this intermediary realm.
Socrates famously says he has a daimon within him that inspires him. So it can refer to an interior inspiration or genius within you. And then by the Christian period, you get this much more polarized demonology. So for summoning a daimon, we have all sorts of formulas, especially found in Roman-era Egypt, because Egypt’s climate is so dry, we get these formulas preserved on papyrus. It sounds almost like a stereotypical magical incantation, like, “Oh daimon, I call upon you, rise up from the earth and speak to me.” They’re very vocative. You’re trying to evoke the spirit to speak to you. Sometimes very supplicatory, like, “I’m coming to you with supplication, please, please listen to me.” So there are various and sundry ways to summon a spirit in ancient Greco-Roman ritual. Off the top of my head, I can’t think of a specific formula, but they are myriad.
What counts as religion?
Jonny Thomson: Well, it’s also interesting because it slightly jumps to a question I was going to ask at the end, but we should probably have it now. And that’s, you know, how do we define religion? How do we define religious belief? Because a lot of people today will subscribe to the main traditional religions, Christianity, Islam, Buddhism, Hinduism, Jainism, etc. But there’s also possibly an even bigger category than that, who believe in ghosts, maybe ancestor worship, maybe they use Ouija boards or horoscopes, and they believe in fate and guardian angels and demons. So would you categorize that broad category as being a religion, or do you define it as something else?
Andrew Henry: Yeah, it’s tricky. I mean, the concept of religion is somewhat modern, and it’s very influenced by Protestant Christianity. So the whole field of religious studies, the academic study of religion, was mostly invented by Protestant scholars back in the late 1800s and 1900s. And so when we think about religion, as an American or as someone who lives in Europe who’s heavily influenced by Protestant Christianity, we think in terms of Protestant Christianity. A religion looks like what Protestant Christianity looks like, which is a founder, Jesus Christ, sacred texts, the Bible consisting of the Old Testament and the New Testament, particular creeds that you swear by, like the Nicene Creed.
And when you look at the world of religion, a lot of religions don’t care all that much about sacred texts or don’t have a founder or don’t care so much about your assent to particular creedal claims. Like there’s one God and that he’s a trinity. Some religions are much more focused on what we could call orthopraxy, correct practice, as opposed to orthodoxy, which is correct teaching or belief. So my first thought would be that religion is not that. That’s a very narrow way to think about religion. And then I would try to parse between a religion, which we call a system of particular practices and beliefs and identities, and religion writ large as this larger category.
I always use what’s called the 3B framework. Religion consists of beliefs, behaviors, and belonging. Beliefs would be those cognitive creedal claims, believing in a particular god or gods. Behaviors would be rituals or moral, ethical guidelines that you follow. And then belonging encompasses religious identity, like I am a Buddhist or I am a Muslim, but also ethnic identities. Yazidism is a religion that’s ethnic and religious. Judaism could be an ethnicity of people and a religion at the same time. So belonging can be very capacious. So just to say that religion is belief in the supernatural is looking at one dimension of religion writ large.
This is a very long way to say that scholars don’t have a satisfactory definition of what counts as religion. If you come up with one, congrats, you have won religious studies, go publish it, you’ll be super famous. The real answer is that there are 100 ways to define religion. 80% of those definitions are crap and you can’t quite capture it. And the more high fidelity you try to get, the more cracks you’ll find in your definition. But there are, I think, more responsible ways to try to define it, either as my 3B framework or the family resemblances model, which is that religion has to check a few boxes like functionaries called priests or shamans or some sort of religious functionary, texts, beliefs, rituals.
And if you check enough boxes, it can count as religion. But of course, there’s always going to be fuzziness around the edges.
Is a stadium chant a religious ritual?
Jonny Thomson: Yeah, and that is very inclusive, obviously, but surely we can push the dial too far. If I say I’m going for a walk and therefore I’m meditating, therefore I’m now a Buddhist, I’m doing orthopraxy. That’s not true, is it? There has to be some kind of black and white line where you say, OK, well, you’re just going for a walk. You’re not a Buddhist. Or, maybe closer to home for a lot of us, is Christmas. I celebrate Christmas. It seems too far to say, oh, therefore you are a Christian.
There has to be surely some kind of absolute point where you can say, well, okay, you’re not really a Buddhist. You should go for a walk.
Andrew Henry: Yeah, I guess I would disagree. There’s a famous debate in the study of religion between an essentialist definition of religion and a functionalist definition of religion. The essentialists say there are prerequisites, there are essential components that religion must have in order for it to be religion. And supernatural belief is often one of those, and affiliation with a particular community is often part of that. And I’m more of a functionalist, and we often punt on the question. We say we can’t quite define this thing that we call religion. We say it’s a modern category that we’ve invented to try to throw particular beliefs and practices into this bucket that we call religion.
I prefer to look at how particular beliefs and practices function in society. So, for example, a collective ritual like chanting the Nicene Creed together in church. Christians, tens of millions, hundreds of millions of Christians every single Sunday chant the Nicene Creed. I believe in one God, almighty maker of heaven and earth. I believe in the Holy Spirit. I believe Jesus. I don’t know it off the top of my head.
But also hundreds of millions of people gather in sporting arenas and chant stuff together, you know, USA, USA during an Olympic game or whatever. And I would say those two things are rituals. They are things that people are chanting together as groups. They’re experiencing similar psychological and physiological responses while doing that practice. And from a functionalist perspective, those rituals are functioning the same in society. They’re creating in-group solidarity. We are all in this together. They’re creating in-group identity. We all here are Americans. We’re chanting USA. Or we all here are Christians and we’re chanting the Nicene Creed.
So looking at it from a functionalist perspective, slapping the label religion on either one of those is kind of artificial. It’s the scholar deciding, oh, I’m going to call this one religious and this one not. And a lot of people get a little bit too excited, like, oh, let’s call them both religious. And let’s call the football stadium religious as well. And I’m like, what is that term really doing? I think it shows that for a lot of people, they privilege religion as this special type of human experience. And as a scholar of religion, I study this stuff as human behavior, I view it all as human behavior.
And let’s just call them both collective rituals and examine how they function in society, creating in-group solidarity, boosting serotonin levels to make you feel more excited or more confident. There’s a lot of research on how rituals boost your psychological feeling of confidence. And the word religion is really not doing all that much. In many respects, it skews things, it makes us focus on some things as more special and view the sporting arena as somehow mundane.
Syncretism and lived religion
Jonny Thomson: But isn’t that the problem with the functionalist model, though? What happens when it leads to incompatible beliefs? So with my walking example, if I call it meditation, therefore I’m a Buddhist, but therefore I’m also a Hindu. Therefore I’m also a mystical Christian. Therefore I’m also a Sufi Muslim, whatever. You could say whatever you want. But those are incompatible beliefs. So by defining it by function, you can’t say I’m all of these things because, A, it’s offensive to a lot of these groups and B, they are incompatible as belief systems.
Andrew Henry: I mean, people are not consistent. So you say incompatible, but people are not consistent.
I forget the study, but there was a survey done a few years ago that found something like 10% of American evangelicals believe in reincarnation. What? Reincarnation has nothing to do with Christianity. Christianity is all about resurrection. Resurrection and reincarnation are very different ideas, yet people hold both, which shows that lived belief rarely follows the neat boundaries that doctrines draw.